Skip to content

Why do onions make you cry?

2 min read · short video · quiz
Short answer

Cutting an onion breaks its cells, and two enzymes quickly turn sulfur compounds into an irritating gas. When the gas reaches your eyes, it stings the nerves there, and your eyes make tears to wash it out.

From knife to tears

1
You cut

The knife breaks open the onion's cells.

2
A gas forms

Two enzymes turn sulfur compounds into an irritating gas.

3
Your eyes water

The gas stings your eyes, and tears wash it away.

You pick up a knife, slice an onion, and a few seconds later your eyes are burning and watering like you’re watching a sad movie. So why do onions make you cry? The onion is defending itself, and your eyes are defending themselves right back.

An onion is a tiny chemistry set

Inside every onion cell, the ingredients for an irritant are kept apart. Sulfur compounds sit in one part of the cell, and an enzyme called alliinase is stored separately. As long as the cells are whole, nothing happens.

When your knife breaks the cells open, those ingredients mix. The alliinase turns the sulfur compounds into new chemicals in a fraction of a second. It’s the same reaction that gives a fresh onion its sharp smell.

Why onions make you cry: one enzyme

For a long time, scientists thought alliinase did all the work. Then, in 2002, a team in Japan found a second enzyme, which they named lachrymatory factor synthase. It grabs one of the new chemicals and quickly rearranges it into a gas called syn-propanethial-S-oxide. That gas is the one that makes you cry.

Garlic is a close relative of the onion and has alliinase too, but it lacks that second enzyme. That’s why chopping garlic smells strong but doesn’t bring tears.

Your eyes fight back

The gas is light and drifts up from the cutting board straight toward your face. When it reaches your eyes, it irritates the nerves on their surface. Your brain reads that as “something is in my eye” and tells your tear glands to start pumping.

Those tears are reflex tears. Their job is to dilute the irritant and wash it away, the same way your eyes water when dust or smoke gets in them. The burning stops once the gas is gone.

How to cry less

Since the gas has to travel through the air, anything that slows it down or keeps it away from your eyes helps. Chill the onion in the fridge for 20 to 30 minutes first, because cold slows the reactions and the gas. Use a sharp knife, which cuts cleanly through cells instead of crushing many of them.

Work near an open window or a fan so the gas drifts away from you. Some cooks also cut the root end last, since that part tends to be the most pungent. Swim goggles look silly, but they work every time.

Not all onions are equal

Some onions make you cry much more than others. It depends on how much sulfur the plant took up from the soil and how much of the tear-making enzyme it has. Sweet onions are usually grown in low-sulfur soil, so they tend to be milder on your eyes as well as your tongue.

People also ask

Do onion tears hurt your eyes?

No. They sting for a moment, but reflex tears are a harmless way for your eyes to flush out the irritant.

Does cutting onions under water help?

It can, because the gas dissolves in water before reaching your eyes, but it makes cutting slippery and awkward.

Why do cooked onions not make you cry?

Heat destroys the enzymes that make the gas, so cooking an onion stops the reaction.

Are there tearless onions?

Yes. Some varieties have been bred to make very little of the tear-causing gas.

Quick quiz